Federal Crimes Blog

When Should You Take Your Federal Criminal Case to Trial?

Posted by Hedding Law Firm | Mar 20, 2020

This is an important question because a lot of times people don't want to plead guilty.  They don't want to go to federal prison and serve 85% of the time and the bottom line is, they don't feel like they've done anything wrong.

So, they're thinking about taking their case to trial, and obviously, the short answer to that question is, you take your federal criminal case to trial when you have a good chance of winning. To give readers a better understanding of when you should take your case to trial, our federal criminal defense attorneys are providing an overview below.

Reviewing Benefits of a Federal Plea Bargain

You don't want to take a trial to lose because then you lose a lot of benefits that you can get by working out a plea bargain.  You get three levels off for acceptance and responsibility.  A lot of times you're not going to have to plead to all the charges.  You just put yourself in a much better position not to get some huge sentence if you work out a deal with the government.

But the bottom line is, you shouldn't have to work out a deal with the government if you're innocent. So, you really need to huddle up with your criminal defense attorney and talk about all the evidence the government has against you, that they're going to use against you t try to convict you and the defenses you have to that evidence and the evidence that you can bring to bear.

Then you have to have a sincere frank discussion with your attorney and listen to your attorney.  I tell people what I really think.  I give them an idea of how I think the prosecutors might be able to beat them and I give them idea of how we might be able to beat the prosecutors and a lot of times it might even come down to the criminal defendant.

In other words, I may say listen, you're going to have to testify in the case in order for us to be successful and if your testimony comes off solid, if it makes sense, if you sound believable and credible then you've got a good chance to win this thing.

If on the other hand, it sounds like you're not telling the truth, you're not giving all the information and you're not credible and you say something that the jury doesn't believe, then I'm going to be saying it's probably not a good idea to go to trial because you're not going to cone off in the best possible light that we need you to in order to be successful.

Reviewing The Strength of Evidence Against You

Then we're also going to look at when we're evaluating whether to do a jury trial in a federal case, how strong the evidence is against you.  In other words, who's going to testify against you?  What's the government going to say?  What's their argument going to be?

When Should You Take Your Federal Criminal Case to Trial?

I challenge prosecutors all the time because I want to hear what they're going to say when I say to them, I think your case is weak.  How are you going to prove this thing against my guy?  You've got problems in this, this and this area.

Then I shut up and listen and I'm going to get something back.  Trust me. If they've filed the case and they're on it and these guys are sophisticated, they're going to come back and give me an idea of why they think they can win the case.

I'm going to take that information back to my client and say, this is what they're saying.  This is how they're going to attack you.

Here's the evidence they have to do it.  Here's how we're going to respond with our evidence and then my client and I really have to evaluate.

Okay, once the jury hears both sides what are they going to do?  In other words, we've got the presumption of innocence on our side, but the government has probably spent considerable time and energy investigating the case.  They wouldn't have filed it if they didn't think they had some good evidence against you.

So, we really need to look at that evidence from a common sense standpoint and say okay, what are the jurors going to do?  Are they going to believe  us?  Are they going to believe them?  What evidence helps us?  What evidence hurts us?

Reviewing Credibility of Witnesses

If they've got evidence that hurts us, is it going to  enough to convict you?  If they've got evidence that hurts us, can we refute the evidence?  Can we attack it.  Can we attack the credibility of a witness that the government's trying to use against you?

These are the types of things you have to evaluate whether or not you're gong to take a case to trial and win, because to me, I don't want to go to trial if we're not going to win, because I'm not going to suffer the consequences.

My client is.  So, I'm looking at this thing from the perspective of either we can win it or we're not going to trial unless you can win the case and beat the government and a lot of times we can do that, but we need to have the evidence and we need to play it the right way.

We need to have the right strategy and we need to do everything we possibly can to get you that result so you don't face the other end of it, which is the federal judge sentencing you after you didn't work the case out with the government.

Hedding Law Firm is a criminal defense law firm located in Los Angeles County at 16000 Ventura Blvd #1208 Encino, CA 91436. We are also located at 633 West Fifth Street Los Angeles, CA 90071. Contact us to review your case at (213) 542-0994.

Related Articles:

About the Author

Contact Us Today

Hedding Law Firm is committed to answering your questions about Federal Criminal Defense issues in Los Angeles and Encino California. We'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.